Indoor gardens are such a godsend for “green” loving people who do not have an outdoor space or are too busy to grow their plants. Those smart devices give us a hand to take care of a range of herbs right inside the comfort of our own home.
This post will review Aerogarden vs Click and Grow – two of the most popular indoor garden systems in the comparing way to see which is more value-for-money. So, let’s get the ball rolling!
Aerogarden Vs Click and Grow Intricate Comparison
Click & Grow utilizes a lightweight, robust plastic material for the production; therefore, its products are generally handy and aesthetically pleasing. They feature a sleek and graceful body design, coming with three color choices – white, beige, and gray.
Besides, Aerogarden’s kits, like Herbie or Farm and Farm Plus, also have a lightweight and sturdy build while bearing a glossy and elegant look. There are plentiful sizes and shapes for users to choose from, such as black, red, sage green, platinum stainless, and stainless steel combinations.
Two gardens can fit easily on a tabletop or a countertop. For us, the Click & Grow garden’s minimalist styling is way more attractive. The gardens can blend right in with any kitchen decor.
Types of Plants Available
The Aerogarden offers a wide range of plants (more than 50 types), including herbs, salad greens, flowers, and vegetables. One cool thing is that its herb garden kits are themed. There are Salsa Mix, Cocktail Herbs, English Cottage, and other offerings for you to pick.
Similarly, Click & Grow produces 44 different sorts of plant pods, ranging from chives, cilantro, sage, parsley to thyme, chili pepper, or sweet potato. Particularly, they have both dwarf basil and dwarf peas available for purchase. We tried the tomato and the basil. They tasted so fresh yet delicious.
Both gardens have a broad selection of seed pods to be grown. However, they differ from each other in one point – Experimental Refill.
If the garden doesn’t have the plants that you planned to grow, Click & Grow will provide you with the experimental plant pods. You can put in your own seeds and have a go at germinating any flora you wish. Without this plus feature, Aerogarden may have given way to its rival.
Yield is one of the most critical factors in weighing up if that garden is for you or not. Let’s look at the Aerogarden Harvest and Click & Grow Smart Garden 3 to have a more precise comparison overview.
The Harvest is able to accommodate anywhere at a maximum of six plants, whereas the Smart Garden 3 can support three plants at one time. As seen, at the nearly same price level, you get a twice larger yield with the Harvest.
That means you can grow a greater number of flowers while saving more money, going for Aerogarden. More plants in approximately the same space are, apparently, much better in our point of view.
With the Click and Grow, it may take several weeks for the herbs to germinate large enough to harvest, and the quantity is relatively small. This garden is suited to grow herbs and flowers for garnish rather than feeding ourselves.
Aerogarden relies on the Hydroponic system – a method of growing plants without the utilization of traditional soils. In fact, the nutrients are dissolved in the proper portions of the water and transferred directly to the roots. This medium is extremely time-efficient when it comes to producing large vegetables, like tomato or cucumber.
Meanwhile, Click and Grow takes advantage of its special soil called Smart soil. The soil releases the nutrients at the right proportion at the right time and boosts the seed-to-bloom growth process of your plants rapidly.
Particularly, this type of soil is exceedingly mineral-rich. It has all the nutrients and components that herbs need to grow healthy. Smart soil’s pH balance and little patches of oxygen will allow your herbs to absorb the nutrients from the wet soil.
The two soil systems are aimed to provide the green vegetables with adequate supplements and nutrients. They both score one point in this term.
Most AeroGarden kits are not reasonably quiet due to the hydroponic system. We actually experienced a soft humming sound emitted from the water pump’s motor when activating our Aerogarden.
Its sound rating is approximately 34-38 decibels. They may get even louder if roots or other pieces of thing get stuck in the impeller.
Indeed, this rate is not really an issue compared to other similar indoor garden models in the market. However, this is still something to take into account. If you are used to silence, especially when reading or sleeping, it can be a bit annoying.
We suggest cleaning the water pump filters every water change. This act helps to keep things running more quietly.
On the other hand, Click & Grow gains the ground on its competitor in this place as the garden doesn’t have a water pump inside the base. It is an entirely silent unit, meaning that users will never have to worry about distracting noises.
Ease Of Use
Both of the two indoor smart gardens deliver great ease of use and worthy convenience. The kits give you everything you need to take care of your plants.
Click and Grow is a remarkably simple unit to run. The only indicator on it is to inform you of when the water or components need refilling. All you need to do is add your seed pods, fill up with water, then plugin. Thus, users can keep an eye on their indoor gardens sporadically without worrying that the little seedlings would suddenly die.
Besides, the Aerogarden offers more customizable controls. You can select an interactive LCD screen, a touch screen, or a push-button control panel model.
Plus, the AeroGarden mobile app functions as the second control panel. The app allows you to get reminders and monitor the lights when you are away. Producers have incorporated different reminders into this mobile application, including “add water” and “add nutrients” to serve consumers the best convenience. Not only that, the app also enables you to reorder supplies, pick up gardening tips or get access to your fav social media platforms.
Click and Grow is such an easy-to-use kit that even children are able to use on their own. However, Aerogarden requires more steps than its rival, asking you to be more involved. Its control system may make it mildly harder for beginners to operate.
Either Click and Grow or Aerogarden uses automated mimic sunlight with adjustable height selections. The lighting of Click and Grow has a modular setup, letting you add the extensions when your flowers get taller. Its maximum plant height is 10.2 inches – suitable for short to medium-high plants.
Besides, its opponent features a convertible arm, reaching a maximum of up to 12 inches. In other words, you can grow a range of higher plants under the Aerogarden’s LED lighting than the Click and Grow’s one.
While Click & Grow’s light output is only 8 to 13 watts, Aerogarden’s one is much stronger, ranging from 10 to 60 watts (far brighter than a normal home light comfort). You won’t realize a considerable change on your power bill, stirring only from $4 to 7$ of electricity per year.
That difference leads to both upsides and downsides. With the Aerogarden, too bright LED grow lights will impact your room’s lighting. Some may find the brightness a bit disturbing. To cope with this problem, you should avoid placing the garden in the bedrooms or around their relaxation space.
On the flip side, it may become an issue if you use the Click & Grow in a dim-light room or in areas where the winter lasts long, hence poor light conditions. Additional lighting should be used in this case to track your plants’ growing process.
Click and Grow will provide your herbs with 16-hour lighting, whereas Aerogarden’s lights are on for 15 hours. Particularly, they feature a built-in timer, which automates the on/off cycle and creates mimic nighttime by automatically turning the LED lighting off for 8 hours.
Thanks to the wicking system and the floating indicator rising and falling with the level of water, you don’t have to water your flowers every day. All you need to do is refill the water tank periodically ( usually one month), and it will automatically moisten your plants. The built-in sensors and timers will let the garden know when to water them.
The Aerogarden’s watering system comprises a water pump and reservoir. They will spread the water in the base and treat the herbs by their roots. The pump’s running cycle is 5 minutes every 25 minutes. Therefore, the water is frequently oxygenated and never gets stagnant.
If you wish, you can also initiate the pump manually based on the water indicator. It’ll turn red when the garden needs refilling.
Indeed, the watering system of Aerogarden tends to be more advanced and does a better job of keeping plants fresh than its rival.
Both of the two gardens on the costly side. Not only the unit but also the refills, fertilizer, and LED grow lights are likely to cost you a fortune. One way to avoid these costs is to reuse the seed pods with your own growing medium. We tried and saved a large sum of money.
Aerogarden may prove to be more pricey than the latter one, particularly when you need to refill it after a couple of months. Typically, vegetables are collected after about six months, while herbs should be harvested after four months.
Obviously, indoor gardens are not the most affordable way to grow plants. But you get what you pay for. Achieving a fruitful harvest with healthy vegetables and flowers is worth spending, isn’t it?
Quick Rundown Of Aerogarden and Click & Grow
|Aerogarden||Click & Grow|
– More plant options
– Larger yield
– Hydroponic system
– More enhanced watering system
– Stronger grow lights
– Higher plant heigh
|– Lightweight and more attractive design|
– Experimental Refill
– Smart soil
– Easy to use
– More complicated to use
|– Less effective water pump|
– Smaller yield
Which is better Click and Grow or AeroGarden?
Keeping all the pros and cons in mind, we consider both indoor gardens are worth-buying products. They have shown off unique qualities and dominated their own stages.
Should you want to add some fun to a standard plant-growing, we highly recommend the Aerogarden. This range offers more growing space and more plants available.
Particularly, the Aerogarden kit suits experienced growers perfectly due to its advanced watering system, large growing space, and effective control panels. That’s why we will lean towards this garden if we were to pick.
Nevertheless, we believe that Click and Grow will be a nice option for every beginner. From its appearance to its functioning systems, manufacturers have succeeded in highlighting the simplification of their products.
Click and Grow is literally born for those who wish to keep things simple, and indoor gardening is as painless as possible. The garden will cover you with great ease of use, silent-whisper watering, and aesthetic style.
To sum up, two gardens should provide you with fresh, healthy, and tasty vegetables. We promise you won’t go wrong with either of them.
Indoor smart gardens are the best idea if you desire to grow plants on your tabletops. The two kits above are our top garden kits of choice, performing superb selling points and standing out from the crowd. Please thoroughly read our Aerogarden vs Click and Grow comparison review before purchasing to decide which product is right for you. We’re always here to give you the most useful advice!